7 Best Brown Eyeliners Tested & Rated by Makeup Artists in 2025

Wondering how we select the best products for you? Learn More Our rankings come from analyzing thousands of customer reviews, looking at factors like product quality, brand reputation, and merchant service. These rankings aim to help guide your shopping choices. By using our recommendations, you'll find the best available prices. We may receive a commission on purchases, at no extra cost to you, which supports our work.

Best Value

2

Estée Lauder

Estée Lauder Double Wear Long-Lasting 24H Waterproof Gel Eyeliner Pencil, 02 Espresso

9.7 Long-lasting

9.6 Easy Application

9.4 Waterproof Performance

Why we love it

24-hour waterproof and smudge-proof formula for all-day wear

Smooth gel texture glides on effortlessly without skipping

Ophthalmologist-tested and free of parabens, phthalates, and mineral oil

Main highlights

Key Features

Advanced gel formula combines precision application, 24-hour wear, and waterproof performance with clean, ophthalmologist-tested ingredients.

Ideal for long-lasting eye makeup

Perfect for busy professionals, outdoor activities, and special occasions where long-lasting, smudge-proof eye makeup is essential.

Praised for exceptional durability

Users consistently praise its ability to maintain perfect lines throughout the day, regardless of weather conditions or activity.

9.7

Exceptional

View offer on:

More Deals (1)

View offer on:

More Deals (1)

3

Maybelline New York

Maybelline New York Tattoostudio Waterproof, Long Wearing, Eyeliner Pencil Makeup, Bold Brown, 0.08 oz (Pack of 2)

9.6 Long-lasting

9.4 Smooth Application

9.4 Color Intensity

Why we love it

36-hour waterproof wear with no smudging or fading

Rich color pigments glide on seamlessly in one stroke

Available in multiple vibrant shades from classic to bold

Main highlights

Key Features

Features waterproof formula, intense color payoff, and 36-hour wear time with smudge-proof and sebum-resistant properties.

Ideal for creating long-lasting eye looks

Perfect for achieving precise eye definition that stays put through daily activities, special events, and demanding conditions.

Praised for exceptional staying power

Users consistently praise its remarkable longevity, maintaining perfect definition without fading or smudging throughout extended wear.

9.4

Excellent

View offer on:

More Deals (1)

View offer on:

More Deals (1)

4

Trish McEvoy

Trish McEvoy Intense Gel Eye Liner, Espresso, 1.2 g / 0.04 oz

Main highlights

An intensely pigmented, waterproof gel liner in convenient pencil form.
Smoothly glides on with even, rich, pure definition that will stay put from application to removal.
To achieve an invisible liner look, lift your eyelid and, holding the pencil upright underneath the upper lashes, press and wiggle the liner in between each lash along the lash line. For more intense definition, start at the innermost lash and glide the tip of the pencil along the lash line. For a smokey look, diffuse the line with the built-in smudger.

9.2

Excellent

View offer on:

More Deals (1)

View offer on:

More Deals (1)

5

Bobbi Brown

Bobbi Brown Long Wear Gel Eyeliner

9.4 Long-lasting

9.2 Easy to Apply

9.1 Smooth Texture

Why we love it

Water-proof formula ensures all-day wear without smudging or fading

Gel-based consistency provides precise and smooth application

Rich shimmer finish in Black Mauve adds sophisticated dimension

Main highlights

Key Features

Premium gel eyeliner featuring water-proof formula, precise application, and sophisticated shimmer finish for stunning eye definition.

Ideal for creating professional eye makeup looks

Perfect for achieving dramatic eye looks, special occasions, and everyday wear when long-lasting makeup is essential.

Praised for exceptional staying power

Users consistently praise this eyeliner's ability to stay put throughout the day without smudging or transferring.

9.0

Excellent

View offer on:

More Deals (1)

View offer on:

More Deals (1)

6

Estée Lauder

Estée Lauder Smoke and Brighten Long-Lasting Waterproof Eyeliner Duo, Dark Chocoloate/Rich Bronze

9.2 Long-lasting Wear

9.0 Easy Application

8.9 Versatile Colors

Why we love it

Dual-ended pencil with contrasting colors for versatile eye makeup looks

8-hour waterproof formula with fade and smudge resistance

Ophthalmologist-tested and safe for waterline use

Main highlights

Key Features

Premium dual-ended eyeliner featuring contrasting shades, waterproof formula, and professional-grade staying power for stunning eye definition.

Ideal for creating professional eye makeup looks

Perfect for achieving smoky effects and bright eye looks, with waterline-safe formula allowing creative mixing and matching.

Praised for long-lasting performance

Users love the 8-hour wear time, resistance to smudging, and versatility of having two complementary shades in one product.

8.9

Excellent

View offer on:

More Deals (1)

View offer on:

More Deals (1)

7

Bobbi Brown

Bobbi Brown Perfectly Defined Gel Eyeliner, No. 04 Steel Grey, 0.012 Ounce

Main highlights

Perfect blend of waxes and emollients give intense color that stays true all day
Effortlessly glides on with a creamy and silky-soft texture
Lightweight and comfortable to wear
Item Package Dimension: 3.0" L x 3.0" W x 4.0" H