Logo Best Reviews Radar
US flag

10 Best Brow Pencils for Natural-Looking Arches – Expert Tested 2025

Fact checked by Laurene Rose
Last Updated January 9, 2025
Editor's Choice
1
Motives® Arch Definer Ultra-Fine Brow Pencil – Water Resistant, Long Wearing Brow Makeup for Natural Looking Eyebrows - Precise, Retractable Tip and Spoolie Brush Eyebrow Pencil (Dark Brown)

Market America

Motives® Arch Definer Ultra-Fine Brow Pencil – Water Resistant, Long Wearing Brow Makeup for Natural Looking Eyebrows - Precise, Retractable Tip and Spoolie Brush Eyebrow Pencil (Dark Brown)

9.8 Easy to Use
9.6 Long-lasting
9.5 Natural Look

Why we love it

Ultra-fine retractable tip creates precise, hair-like strokes for natural appearance
Water-resistant and smudge-proof formula ensures long-lasting wear throughout the day
Dual-ended design with spoolie brush for perfect shaping and blending

Main highlights

Key Features

Features waterproof formula, precise retractable tip, and integrated spoolie brush for professional-quality brow grooming and styling.

Ideal for creating perfectly defined eyebrows

Perfect for achieving natural-looking, well-defined brows that stay in place all day without smudging or fading.

Praised for its precision and long-wearing formula

Users love the ultra-fine tip that creates realistic hair-like strokes and the long-lasting formula that maintains shape.

9.9

Exceptional

More Deals (1)
Wondering how we select the best products for you? Learn More
Best Value
2
Plume - Nourish + Define Natural Brow Pencil | Clean, Plant-Based, Vegan (Ashy Daybreak)

Plume

Plume - Nourish + Define Natural Brow Pencil | Clean, Plant-Based, Vegan (Ashy Daybreak)

9.7 Quality Formula
9.7 Easy Application
9.6 Natural Results

Why we love it

Dual-ended design with refillable pencil and spoolie brush for precise application
Natural growth-promoting formula with plant-based ingredients for healthier brows
Available in six versatile shades with long-lasting, preservative-free formula

Main highlights

Key Features

Features dual-ended design, natural growth-promoting ingredients, and six color options for customizable, professional-looking brow enhancement.

Ideal for daily eyebrow grooming and enhancement

Perfect for those seeking a natural-looking, long-lasting brow solution that promotes growth while providing daily definition.

Praised for its natural and sustainable formulation

Customers love the vegan, cruelty-free formula that delivers professional results while maintaining ethical and sustainable standards.

9.7

Exceptional

More Deals (1)
3
KIMIKO Eyebrow Pencil Automatique (Twist Up Pencil, Long Wear Formula, Comes with Covered Brush for Natural Looking Brows) (Latte)

Kimiko Brands

KIMIKO Eyebrow Pencil Automatique (Twist Up Pencil, Long Wear Formula, Comes with Covered Brush for Natural Looking Brows) (Latte)

9.5 Worth the Money
9.3 Long-lasting
9.2 Easy Application

Why we love it

Ultra-precise twist-up tip creates realistic hair-like strokes for natural-looking brows
Long-wearing Japanese formula with clean beauty ingredients and vitamin enrichment
Editor-approved design with no sharpening required for consistent precision

Main highlights

Key Features

Advanced Japanese engineering combines precise application, long-lasting wear, and clean beauty ingredients for professional-grade eyebrow enhancement.

Ideal for Professional Makeup Artists and Daily Use

Perfect for creating detailed, natural-looking brows with consistent precision, whether for professional makeup application or everyday use.

Praised for Natural-Looking Results

Customers love how the ultra-fine tip creates realistic hair-like strokes, delivering professional results with minimal effort.

9.4

Excellent

More Deals (1)
4
Long Wear Brow Pencil - 7 Saddle by Bobbi Brown for Women 0.1 oz Eyebrow Pencil

Bobbi Brown

Long Wear Brow Pencil - 7 Saddle by Bobbi Brown for Women 0.1 oz Eyebrow Pencil

9.4 Long-lasting
9.2 Easy to Apply
9.1 Natural Look

Why we love it

Waterproof formula with chiseled tip for precise application and natural-looking results
Lightweight design with step-by-step guide for foolproof brow styling
All-in-one solution offering versatile strokes from soft to bold definition

Main highlights

Key Features

Features a waterproof formula, chiseled tip design, and lightweight construction for professional-quality brow styling at home.

Ideal for everyday brow styling

Perfect for busy individuals seeking quick, reliable brow enhancement that stays put throughout daily activities.

Praised for its versatile application

Users appreciate the pencil's ability to create both subtle definition and bold structures with its innovative chiseled tip.

9.2

Excellent

More Deals (1)
5
Micro Brow Pencil - Espresso by Bobbi Brown for Women - 0.002 oz Eyebrow Pencil

Bobbi Brown

Micro Brow Pencil - Espresso by Bobbi Brown for Women - 0.002 oz Eyebrow Pencil

9.3 Precision Control
9.1 Natural Look
9.1 Easy Application

Why we love it

Ultra-fine tip creates realistic hair strokes
Precise application for filling sparse areas
Extends and defines eyebrow tails naturally

Main highlights

Key Features

Features ultra-precise tip technology for creating realistic hair strokes, perfect for filling gaps and extending brow shapes.

Ideal for creating natural-looking eyebrow enhancement

Perfect for those seeking to enhance sparse eyebrows with natural-looking results that blend seamlessly with existing brow hair.

Praised for precise hair-like strokes

Users consistently praise the product's ability to create incredibly realistic, hair-like strokes that look natural and last all day.

9.0

Excellent

More Deals (1)
6
Long Wear Brow Pencil - 5 Espresso by Bobbi Brown for Women 0.1 oz Eyebrow Pencil

Bobbi Brown

Long Wear Brow Pencil - 5 Espresso by Bobbi Brown for Women 0.1 oz Eyebrow Pencil

Main highlights

  • Form: Slanted, chiseled brow pencil: This all-in-one brow pencil features a slanted, chiseled tip for soft definition and bold structure
  • Finish: Natural-looking: The natural-finish brow pencil delivers a polished and defined look without appearing overly done
  • Weight: 0.1 ounces: The brow pencil weighs 0.1 ounces, providing a comfortable and easy-to-use experience
  • Specialty: Long Wearing, Waterproof: Designed for long-lasting wear, this brow pencil is waterproof, ensuring a smudge-free and crease-free look throughout the day

8.9

Excellent

More Deals (1)
7
Trish McEvoy Precision Brow Shaper, Natural Blonde, 0.1 g / 0.003 oz

Trish McEvoy

Trish McEvoy Precision Brow Shaper, Natural Blonde, 0.1 g / 0.003 oz

8.9 Easy to Use
8.9 Precision Control
8.8 Natural Look

Why we love it

Ultra-precise lead for detailed brow definition and natural-looking results
Built-in grooming brush helps shape and blend brow hairs perfectly
Firm pencil texture allows controlled application for professional finish

Main highlights

Key Features

Features automatic design, ultra-precise lead, and integrated grooming brush for professional-quality brow styling and natural enhancement

Ideal for creating perfectly defined eyebrows

Perfect for filling sparse areas, defining brow shape, and achieving natural-looking results with precise control

Praised for its precision and ease of use

Users love the convenient built-in brush and firm lead that ensures precise application without smudging

8.7

Very Good

More Deals (1)
8
Bobbi Brown Natural Brow Shaper & Hair Touch Up - Mahogany (BNIB)

Bobbi Brown Natural Brow Shaper & Hair Touch Up - Mahogany (BNIB)

8.5

Very Good

More Deals (1)
9
2 in 1 Magic Eyebrow Pencil, 2024 New 3D Waterproof Microblading Eyebrow Pen, 4 Fork Tip Pencil with Liquid Eyeliner Tip, 2 in 1 Eyebrow Pencil for Natural Looking Eye Makeup (Color*4)

Lagwry

2 in 1 Magic Eyebrow Pencil, 2024 New 3D Waterproof Microblading Eyebrow Pen, 4 Fork Tip Pencil with Liquid Eyeliner Tip, 2 in 1 Eyebrow Pencil for Natural Looking Eye Makeup (Color*4)

Main highlights

  • 【Upgrade Your Brow Game】Our upgraded microblading eyebrow pencil features a unique four-point tip and a double-ended design, Perfect for not just perfecting your brows but also effortlessly applying eyeliner.
  • 【Waterproof & Long-Lasting】Formulated to be waterproof, sweatproof, and transfer-proof, Our microblade eyebrow pencil ensures your brows stay flawless from dawn till dusk.
  • 【Innovative Four-Point Tip】This advanced microblading eyebrow pen boasts a distinctive four-point tip and dual-headed design, Making it versatile for both eyebrow shaping and eyeliner application.
  • 【Perfect for All Skill Levels】Loved by both novices and pros, Our microblading eyebrow pen simplifies color application. With just a few easy steps, You can achieve fuller, lifted brows that enhance your natural beauty.
  • 【Easy & Convenient】Designed to suit a variety of skin tones, Our eyebrow pen complements warm, cool, and neutral undertones, ensuring a perfect match for your skin tone or makeup style. Say goodbye to guesswork and hello to effortless beauty!

8.4

Very Good

More Deals (1)
10
Bobbi Brown Natural Brow Shaper Rich Brown

Bobbi Brown

Bobbi Brown Natural Brow Shaper Rich Brown

Main highlights

  • Natural Brow Shaper Rich Brown

8.2

Good

More Deals (1)
Ulta Beauty 3 Pack Ultra Slim Brow Pencil. Taupe. Size 0.003 oz

Ulta Beauty 3 Pack Ultra Slim Brow Pencil. Taupe. Size 0.003 oz

$36.99
Ulta Beauty 3 Pack Ultra Slim Brow Pencil. Dark Brown. Size 0.003 oz

Ulta Beauty 3 Pack Ultra Slim Brow Pencil. Dark Brown. Size 0.003 oz

$38.98
Long Wear Brow Pencil - 1 Blonde by Bobbi Brown for Women 0.1 oz Eyebrow Pencil

Long Wear Brow Pencil - 1 Blonde by Bobbi Brown for Women 0.1 oz Eyebrow Pencil

$39.99
Long Wear Brow Pencil - 9 Slate by Bobbi Brown for Women 0.1 oz Eyebrow Pencil

Long Wear Brow Pencil - 9 Slate by Bobbi Brown for Women 0.1 oz Eyebrow Pencil

$38.79
$54.35