Logo Best Reviews Radar
US flag

8 Best Drugstore Mascaras Tested in 2025: Top-Rated Under $15

Fact checked by Laurene Rose
Last Updated January 9, 2025
Editor's Choice
1
L'Oreal Paris Voluminous Original Mascara, Carbon Black, 3 Count

L'Oreal Paris

L'Oreal Paris Voluminous Original Mascara, Carbon Black, 3 Count

9.9 Volume Enhancement
9.9 Easy Application
9.8 Long-Lasting Wear

Why we love it

Clump-resistant formula builds lashes up to 5X thicker with specialized brush
Safe for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers with gentle formulation
Works perfectly with lash primer for enhanced volume and length

Main highlights

Key Features

Features volume-maximizing brush, clump-resistant formula, and gentle ingredients suitable for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers.

Ideal for everyday makeup enthusiasts

Perfect for those seeking dramatic lash enhancement while maintaining comfort and ease of application in daily makeup routines.

Praised for volumizing performance

Users consistently praise the mascara's ability to build dramatic volume up to 5X thickness without clumping or irritation.

9.9

Exceptional

More Deals (1)
Wondering how we select the best products for you? Learn More
Best Value
2
Benefit Badgal Bang! Double The Volume Mascara Duo #1 Intense Pitch-Black Set (2×0.3 oz)

Benefit

Benefit Badgal Bang! Double The Volume Mascara Duo #1 Intense Pitch-Black Set (2×0.3 oz)

9.8 Long-Lasting
9.7 Easy Application
9.5 Value for Money

Why we love it

Adds dramatic volume and length to lashes while staying water-resistant
Ensures smudge-free wear throughout the day with lasting formula
Professional-grade mascara that delivers intense black coverage

Main highlights

Key Features

Advanced formula combines volumizing properties with water-resistant technology for stunning, long-lasting lash enhancement throughout the day.

Ideal for active lifestyles and long-wear needs

Perfect for busy professionals, gym-goers, and special occasions where lasting, smudge-proof makeup performance is essential.

Praised for its exceptional staying power

Users consistently highlight its ability to maintain volume and definition without smudging or flaking, even in challenging conditions.

9.7

Exceptional

More Deals (1)
3
Clarins Supra Volume Mascara | Award-Winning | Volumizing and Lengthening | Double Volume Effect | Visibly Thickens and Smoothes Lashes | Clump-Free and Smudge-Proof | Long-Wearing | 0.2 Ounces

Clarins

Clarins Supra Volume Mascara | Award-Winning | Volumizing and Lengthening | Double Volume Effect | Visibly Thickens and Smoothes Lashes | Clump-Free and Smudge-Proof | Long-Wearing | 0.2 Ounces

Main highlights

  • Achieve full, voluminous lashes in one quick coat. This double volume effect mascara is formulated with natural ingredients, including Cassie Flower wax and Panthenol to visibly thicken and smoothe lashes.
  • A clump-free, smudge-proof mascara that volumizes and lengthens lashes with intense color pay-off.
  • Recommended for younger to mature skin and for all skin types.

9.4

Excellent

More Deals (1)
4
Too Faced Naturally Better Than Sex Mascara | Volumizing + Curling, 0.26 Fl Oz, Black

Too Faced

Too Faced Naturally Better Than Sex Mascara | Volumizing + Curling, 0.26 Fl Oz, Black

9.6 Natural Formula
9.4 Safe for Eyes
9.3 Lash Enhancement

Why we love it

98% naturally-derived ingredients with bamboo fibers for enhanced volume
Vegan formula safe for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers
Contains Goji Berry Blend and Lash Nourishing Complex for conditioning

Main highlights

Natural Beauty Enhancement

Features bamboo fibers, goji berry blend, and natural ingredients that work together to create voluminous, longer-looking lashes.

Ideal for Sensitive Eyes and Daily Wear

Perfect for those seeking a gentle, ophthalmologist-tested mascara that delivers results while being safe for sensitive eyes.

Praised for Safe and Natural Formula

Customers love the natural formula that conditions lashes while providing dramatic volume and length without irritation.

9.2

Excellent

More Deals (1)
5
Lancôme Monsieur Big Volumizing Mascara - Up To 12x More Volume & 24H Wear - False Lash Effect - Black

Lancôme

Lancôme Monsieur Big Volumizing Mascara - Up To 12x More Volume & 24H Wear - False Lash Effect - Black

Main highlights

  • VOLUMIZING MASCARA, with a false lash effect providing up to 12x more volume* and up to 24H of wear for your most dramatic lashes yet.
  • VOLUMIZING & LENGTHENING, is smudge-proof and does not flake.The soft brush and wavy fiber bristles deliver high intensity ultra-black pigments, evenly coating each lash for clump-free volume.
  • WAVY FIBERS, Innovative bristle fibers for quick volume and sensorial application.
  • BIG FORMULA, our blackest formula with longwearing polymers and volumizing supple waxes.
  • FRANCE HAS A WORD FOR BEAUTY: LANCÔME - Since its founding in 1935 by visionary parfumeur Armand Petitjean, the luxury brand has been synonymous with efficacy, innovation, and French elegance.

9.0

Excellent

More Deals (1)
6
Lancôme Lash Idôle Lash-Lifting & Volumizing Mascara - Black Mascara for Instant Volume, Length & Lift - Smudge Proof & Up To 24H Wear - Black

Lancôme

Lancôme Lash Idôle Lash-Lifting & Volumizing Mascara - Black Mascara for Instant Volume, Length & Lift - Smudge Proof & Up To 24H Wear - Black

9.4 Long-Lasting
9.3 Easy Application
9.1 Clump-Free Results

Why we love it

Dual-sided curved wand with 360-degree micro-bristles for precise application
24-hour lasting formula with no flaking or smudging
95% of users reported instant lash lift and volume

Main highlights

Key Features

Features advanced curved wand technology, lightweight gel formula, and 360-degree micro-bristles for comprehensive lash enhancement and volumizing effects.

Ideal for achieving professional-looking lash enhancement

Perfect for daily wear, special occasions, and achieving dramatic lash transformations without extensions or false lashes.

Praised for its innovative dual-sided wand design

Users love the versatile wand design that allows precise application, delivering both volume and length while keeping lashes separated.

8.9

Excellent

More Deals (1)
7
Benefit Double Deal They're Real Mascara - 2pcs 8.5g / 2 full size mascaras

Benefit Cosmetics

Benefit Double Deal They're Real Mascara - 2pcs 8.5g / 2 full size mascaras

9.3 Long-Lasting
9.1 Easy to Apply
9.0 Volumizing Effect

Why we love it

Lengthening formula creates dramatically long lashes with special brush design
Full-size duo package provides excellent value for premium mascara
Custom brush with precision bristles separates and defines each lash

Main highlights

Key Features

Features innovative brush design, long-wearing formula, and special lengthening fibers that create stunning, defined lashes with each application.

Ideal for achieving dramatic eye looks

Perfect for daily wear, special occasions, and creating bold eye looks that require maximum lash length and definition.

Praised for exceptional lengthening results

Customers consistently praise this mascara's ability to create noticeably longer lashes while maintaining a natural, clump-free appearance.

8.7

Very Good

More Deals (1)
8
Lancôme Cils Booster XL Enhancing Lash & Mascara Primer - Infused with Micro-fibers, Vitamin B5 and Vitamin E - Boosts Mascara Volume, Length & Curl

Lancôme

Lancôme Cils Booster XL Enhancing Lash & Mascara Primer - Infused with Micro-fibers, Vitamin B5 and Vitamin E - Boosts Mascara Volume, Length & Curl

Main highlights

  • A conditioning formula for visible performance, infused with micro-fibers, Vitamin B5 and Vitamin E.
  • This revitalizing lash primer will improve lash results, thickness and curl over time.
  • White in color. Cils Booster XL leaves lashes feeling luxurious and soft, while allowing the pigment of your favorite mascara to stand out, thus, creating an intense and rich false-lash look.
  • Cils Booster XL can also be worn overnight as a “lash mask.”Simply apply on clean lashes to nourish and rejuvenate before bed.
  • FRANCE HAS A WORD FOR BEAUTY: LANCÔME - Since its founding in 1935 by visionary parfumeur Armand Petitjean, the luxury brand has been synonymous with efficacy, innovation, and French elegance.

8.5

Very Good

More Deals (1)
Lancôme Définicils Defining & Lengthening Mascara - For Natural-Looking Lashes - With Vitamin B5 - Black

Lancôme Définicils Defining & Lengthening Mascara - For Natural-Looking Lashes - With Vitamin B5 - Black

$34.00
Make Up For Ever Smoky Extravagant Mascara, Black, 0.23 Ounce

Make Up For Ever Smoky Extravagant Mascara, Black, 0.23 Ounce

$38.99
$42.99
LashSense VolumeIntense Mascara - Black

LashSense VolumeIntense Mascara - Black

$33.99