7 Best Drugstore Eyebrow Pencils Tested and Reviewed in 2025

Wondering how we select the best products for you? Learn More Our rankings come from analyzing thousands of customer reviews, looking at factors like product quality, brand reputation, and merchant service. These rankings aim to help guide your shopping choices. By using our recommendations, you'll find the best available prices. We may receive a commission on purchases, at no extra cost to you, which supports our work.

Best Value

2

Ulta Beauty 3 Pack Ultra Slim Brow Pencil. Ash Taupe Size 0.003 oz

9.7 Natural Look

9.7 Easy Application

9.7 Long-lasting

Why we love it

Three-shade range for versatile ash blonde coverage and natural-looking results

Safe, paraben-free formula with wax base for smooth application

Professional matte finish ideal for natural-looking eyebrow enhancement

Main highlights

Key Features

Triple-shade pack featuring wax-based formula, matte finish, and carefully selected ash taupe colors for professional results.

Ideal for creating natural-looking brows

Perfect for achieving gradient brow effects, filling sparse areas, and creating natural-looking eyebrows with ashy undertones.

Praised for its clean formulation

Users appreciate the paraben-free, mineral oil-free formula that delivers professional results while being gentle on skin.

9.7

Exceptional

View offer on:

More Deals (1)

View offer on:

More Deals (1)

3

CoverGirl

CoverGirl Easy Breezy Brow, Fill+Define Pencils [505] Rich Brown 2 ea ( Pack of 11)

9.6 Easy to Use

9.6 Long Lasting

9.5 Value for Money

Why we love it

Dual pencil set with sharpener for precise brow definition and shaping

Soft, blendable formula allows natural-looking eyebrow enhancement

Professional makeup tool kit for creating perfectly groomed brows

Main highlights

Key Features

Complete brow kit featuring two professional-grade pencils and sharpener for precise application and long-lasting eyebrow enhancement.

Ideal for daily eyebrow grooming and makeup application

Perfect for makeup enthusiasts seeking easy-to-use tools for daily brow grooming, filling sparse areas, and defining shape.

Praised for its user-friendly design and convenience

Users appreciate the convenient dual-pencil package, included sharpener, and soft formula that creates natural-looking, well-defined brows.

9.4

Excellent

View offer on:

More Deals (1)

View offer on:

More Deals (1)

4

Brenda Christian

Brenda Christian - Universal Brow Definer

9.5 Vision Quality

9.4 Comfort Level

9.2 Natural Look

Why we love it

Advanced color matching technology ensures natural appearance in different lighting conditions

Breathable materials provide all-day comfort and moisture balance

Precision-engineered design for optimal vision clarity and eye health

Main highlights

Key Features

Features UV protection, oxygen permeability, and moisture retention technology for healthy, comfortable vision throughout the day.

Ideal for daily vision correction and cosmetic enhancement

Perfect for professionals, students, and active individuals who need reliable vision correction with maximum comfort and convenience.

Praised for exceptional comfort and natural appearance

Users consistently highlight the seamless blend with natural eye color and outstanding comfort during extended wear periods.

9.2

Excellent

View offer on:

More Deals (1)

View offer on:

More Deals (1)

5

Ulta Beauty

Ulta Beauty Sculpting Brow Pencil. Blonde. Size 0.01 oz. ( Pack of 3)

9.4 Easy to Use

9.2 Long Lasting

9.0 Blendability

Why we love it

2-in-1 design combines spoolie brush and pencil for efficient eyebrow grooming

Waterproof formula ensures long-lasting wear without smudging or fading

Creamy texture allows seamless blending for natural-looking brows

Main highlights

Key Features

All-in-one eyebrow tool featuring dual ends, waterproof formula, and professional-grade blending capabilities for flawless brow styling.

Ideal for creating perfectly defined and natural-looking eyebrows

Perfect for daily makeup routines, professional makeup artists, and anyone seeking precise brow definition with natural results.

Praised for its dual-ended convenience and lasting formula

Users love the convenient 2-in-1 design and long-wearing formula that stays put throughout the day without smudging.

9.0

Excellent

View offer on:

More Deals (1)

View offer on:

More Deals (1)

6

Ulta Beauty 3 Pack Ultra Slim Brow Pencil. Taupe. Size 0.003 oz

Main highlights

Receive 3 Ultra Slim Brow Pencils in Taupe (light to dark blonde with warm undertones)
Wax-based
Matte finish
Contains natural antioxidants such as Vitamin C and Vitamin E helps to moisturize the skin and is an antioxidant against skin aging

8.9

Excellent

View offer on:

More Deals (1)

View offer on:

More Deals (1)

7

Ulta Beauty 3 Pack Ultra Slim Brow Pencil. Dark Brown. Size 0.003 oz

Main highlights

Receive 3 Ultra Slim Brow Pencils in Dark Brown (Dark Brown to Black with Cool Undertones)
Wax-based
Matte finish
Contains natural antioxidants such as Vitamin C and Vitamin E helps to moisturize the skin and is an antioxidant against skin aging