Logo Best Reviews Radar
US flag

8 Best Eyeliners Tested & Reviewed: Expert Picks for 2025

Fact checked by Olivia Williams
Last Updated January 8, 2025
Editor's Choice
1
Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil 3-Pc Liner Giftset (Perversion, Demolition, Yeyo), Smudge-Proof, Transfer-proof, Long-lasting Colored Eye Liners, Hydrating Vitamin E, Cruelty-free

Urban Decay

Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil 3-Pc Liner Giftset (Perversion, Demolition, Yeyo), Smudge-Proof, Transfer-proof, Long-lasting Colored Eye Liners, Hydrating Vitamin E, Cruelty-free

9.8 Long-lasting Color
9.7 Smooth Application
9.7 Color Variety

Why we love it

Waterproof formula with 24/7 long-wearing color that stays put
30 vibrant shades available in 5 different finishes for versatile looks
Hydrating ingredients including vitamin E, jojoba oil, and cottonseed oil

Main highlights

Key Features

Premium waterproof eyeliner featuring award-winning formula, extensive color range, and nourishing ingredients for long-lasting wear.

Ideal for creating versatile eye looks

Perfect for achieving various eye makeup styles, from subtle daytime looks to dramatic evening effects with multiple finish options.

Praised for smooth application and comfort

Users love the creamy texture that glides effortlessly without pulling, while providing intense color and comfortable all-day wear.

9.9

Exceptional

More Deals (1)
Wondering how we select the best products for you? Learn More
Best Value
2
stila Stay All Day® Dual-Ended Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner, 0.033 fl. Oz, 1 Count (Pack of 1)

stila

stila Stay All Day® Dual-Ended Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner, 0.033 fl. Oz, 1 Count (Pack of 1)

9.6 Long-lasting
9.6 Precision Control
9.4 Easy Application

Why we love it

Dual-tip design with precision and micro tips for versatile application
Waterproof and smudge-proof formula that stays all day
PETA-certified cruelty-free liquid eyeliner with quick-drying formula

Main highlights

Key Features

Double-sided pen featuring waterproof formula, precision and micro tips, quick-drying performance, and long-lasting wear throughout the day.

Ideal for Creating Versatile Eye Looks

Perfect for achieving various looks from natural definition to dramatic lines, with easy application between lashes for fuller appearance.

Praised for Professional-Grade Precision

Users appreciate the superior control and accuracy provided by dual tips, allowing precise application and smudge-free wear.

9.7

Exceptional

More Deals (1)
3
treasure.of.egypt 4 PCS Original Bell waterproof Black Eyeliner Pencil, Long-Wearing, Smudge-Proof, Germany Made

treasure.of.egypt

treasure.of.egypt 4 PCS Original Bell waterproof Black Eyeliner Pencil, Long-Wearing, Smudge-Proof, Germany Made

9.5 Long-lasting
9.4 Easy to Apply
9.2 Smudge-proof

Why we love it

Highly pigmented and water-resistant formula for bold, long-lasting eye makeup
Ultra-smooth, creamy texture applies effortlessly with one swipe application
Versatile for smoking, shaping, and precision eye looks with smudge-proof finish

Main highlights

Key Features

Premium German-made eyeliner featuring water-resistant formula, rich pigmentation, and ultra-smooth application for professional-quality eye makeup results.

Ideal for Professional Makeup Artists and Daily Wear

Perfect for creating versatile eye looks, from precise lines to smokey effects, suitable for both professional use and everyday wear.

Praised for Long-lasting Performance

Users consistently praise its smudge-proof formula, long-lasting wear, and ability to maintain bold color throughout the day.

9.4

Excellent

More Deals (1)
4
Estée Lauder Double Wear Long-Lasting Infinite Waterproof Eyeliner, Espresso

Estée Lauder

Estée Lauder Double Wear Long-Lasting Infinite Waterproof Eyeliner, Espresso

9.3 Long-lasting Performance
9.1 Easy Application
8.9 Versatile Usage

Why we love it

24-hour waterproof and smudge-resistant formula for all-day wear
Built-in sharpener and smudger tip for versatile application styles
Ophthalmologist-tested and humidity-resistant for comfort and durability

Main highlights

Key Features

Premium eyeliner featuring 24-hour wear, waterproof formula, built-in tools, and professional-grade performance for flawless application.

Ideal for long-lasting eye makeup looks

Perfect for creating precise lines, smoky effects, and maintaining makeup through intense activities and various weather conditions.

Praised for exceptional durability

Users consistently praise its long-wearing formula, resistance to smudging, and ability to maintain color intensity throughout the day.

9.2

Excellent

More Deals (1)
5
Heroine Make by KISSME Eyeliner Trio Set | 3 Full-Size - Waterproof Smooth Liquid Eyeliner, Japanese Eye Makeup for Smudge-free, Super Keep 01 Jet Black

Isehan Co., Ltd.

Heroine Make by KISSME Eyeliner Trio Set | 3 Full-Size - Waterproof Smooth Liquid Eyeliner, Japanese Eye Makeup for Smudge-free, Super Keep 01 Jet Black

9.1 Precision Control
9.0 Long-lasting Performance
9.0 Quality Design

Why we love it

Ultra-fine tip delivers precise lines with exceptional control and accuracy
Waterproof and smudge-proof formula ensures all-day wear in any condition
Japanese craftsmanship guarantees premium quality and reliable performance

Main highlights

Key Features

Features ultra-fine tip application, waterproof formula, quick-drying properties, and ergonomic design for maximum control and comfort.

Ideal for creating professional eye makeup looks

Perfect for achieving sharp winged liner, detailed eye makeup designs, and long-lasting looks for both casual and professional wear.

Praised for its precision and staying power

Users consistently praise its precise application, smudge-resistant formula, and ability to maintain perfect lines throughout the day.

9.0

Excellent

More Deals (1)
6
Estée Lauder Double Wear Long-Lasting 24H Waterproof Gel Eyeliner Pencil, 05 Smoke

Estée Lauder

Estée Lauder Double Wear Long-Lasting 24H Waterproof Gel Eyeliner Pencil, 05 Smoke

Main highlights

  • PRECISION DEFINITION: Get the perfect line, rain or shine. Effortlessly apply intense color for the eye look you want. This easy-to-apply gel pencil glides on smoothly without ever skipping, tugging or dragging.
  • 24-HOUR LONG WEAR: The look you see in the morning is the look you keep all day. Waterproof. Smudge-proof. Lightweight plus long wear. Resists humidity, sweat and transferring.
  • SETS IN SECONDS: Wears for 24 hours. Sets in seconds. To soften line, blend before it sets with soft smudge tip.
  • FORMULA FACTS: Ophthalmologist-tested. Fragrance-free. 24-hour wear. Waterproof. Smudge-proof. Transfer-resistant. Plus, it’s free of parabens, phthalates and mineral oil.
  • HIGH-PERFORMANCE LONGWEAR: Discover the complete Double Wear Collection. From our #1 foundation, to concealer, eye liners and more, it's makeup that keeps up with your busy day. The flawless look you see in the morning is the look you keep all day.

8.9

Excellent

More Deals (1)
7
Kosas Soulgazer Intensifying Waterproof Gel Eyeliner - Depth (warm brown matte). Bonus Premium Korean Sheet Masque with Collagen

Kosas

Kosas Soulgazer Intensifying Waterproof Gel Eyeliner - Depth (warm brown matte). Bonus Premium Korean Sheet Masque with Collagen

Main highlights

  • A clean, waterproof, retractable gel eyeliner powered by hyaluronic acid for the smoothest glide and easiest application in eye-intensifying colors.
  • This unique, creamy, waterproof gel eyeliner has quick playtime and blendability before it locks into place.
  • The everyday basics-but-better shades across matte and satin finishes are designed to amplify your eye color for soul-piercing eyes that pop.
  • The retractable pencil also has a built-in sharpener and smudger for any look.
  • Color: Depth - warm brown matte. Size 0.012 oz / 0.35 g
  • You will also get a gift - ENTEL-Pomegranate Sheet Mask Pack with Collagen for instant hydration, tone evening, and lifting. Size: 25g / 0.88 oz. Made in Korea.

8.7

Very Good

More Deals (1)
8
Estée Lauder Smoke and Brighten Long-Lasting Waterproof Eyeliner Duo, Dark Chocoloate/Rich Bronze

Estée Lauder

Estée Lauder Smoke and Brighten Long-Lasting Waterproof Eyeliner Duo, Dark Chocoloate/Rich Bronze

Main highlights

  • EYE-OPENING LOOKS: Line & define with this dual-ended creamy pencil featuring two contrasting high-impact hues. Define shade creates smoky definition. Illuminate shade makes eyes pop.
  • 8-HOUR POWER: Get high-performance lining & defining. 8-hour wear. 8-hour fade resistance. 8-hour color true. 8-hour non-flaking, non-creasing and non-settling. Plus, it’s waterproof. Sweat- and humidity-resistant.
  • FORMULA FACTS: Ophthalmologist-tested, and it’s appropriate for use on waterline.
  • INSIDER TIP: Feeling creative? Mix, match & customize your look however you want! Both shades are waterline safe so you can Smoke & Brighten, your way.

8.5

Very Good

More Deals (1)
Estée Lauder Little Black Liner Thick. Thin. Ultra-Fine. | Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner

Estée Lauder Little Black Liner Thick. Thin. Ultra-Fine. | Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner

$36.00
Chanel Yeux Stylo Waterproof, Long Lasting Eyeliner, 943 BRUN AGAPE (0.30g/0.01oz)

Chanel Yeux Stylo Waterproof, Long Lasting Eyeliner, 943 BRUN AGAPE (0.30g/0.01oz)

$34.99
sisley paris Sisley Phyto Khol Star Waterproof - 01 Sparkling Black By Sisley for Women - 0.01 Oz Eyeliner,0.10 Oz

sisley paris Sisley Phyto Khol Star Waterproof - 01 Sparkling Black By Sisley for Women - 0.01 Oz Eyeliner,0.10 Oz

$44.71
$55.00
Chanel Stylo Yeux Waterproof - # 83 Cassis 0.3g/0.01oz [Misc.]

Chanel Stylo Yeux Waterproof - # 83 Cassis 0.3g/0.01oz [Misc.]

$45.00
Clarins Waterproof Eye Pencil | Award-Winning | Highly Pigmented and Long-Wearing | Includes Retractable Tip, Built-In Sharpener and Smudger For Smoky Eye Looks | 0.01 Ounces

Clarins Waterproof Eye Pencil | Award-Winning | Highly Pigmented and Long-Wearing | Includes Retractable Tip, Built-In Sharpener and Smudger For Smoky Eye Looks | 0.01 Ounces

$30.00